Advanced Methodology for Penetration Testing Applications & APIs Behind a Firewall/WAF

MITRE ATT&CK Framework
MITRE Attack Framework 101: All You Need to Know  
July 19, 2024
CVE-2019-8805: Apple EndpointSecurity framework Privilege Escalation
July 19, 2024

July 19, 2024

Penetration testing applications and APIs behind a Web Application Firewall (WAF) requires sophisticated techniques to bypass protective measures. Here is an advanced and detailed methodology from an attacker’s perspective.

Preparation Phase

The preparation phase is crucial for setting the foundation for an effective penetration test. This phase involves gathering comprehensive information about the target environment, which helps in understanding the defenses and potential attack vectors. Let’s take a closer look at this phase. 

In this initial phase, the focus is on understanding the specific WAF/firewall technologies in use, configurations, and rules. Key activities include mapping the network architecture and segmentation, and gathering details about the application stack, including software versions, frameworks, and third-party components.

Reconnaissance Phase

The reconnaissance phase involves gathering as much information as possible about the target environment without interacting directly with the systems in a way that could be detected. This phase is divided into passive and active reconnaissance to cover all potential information sources.

Passive Reconnaissance

The goal is to gather public information using WHOIS records, DNS records, Shodan, Censys, and other online databases. Tools like Sublist3r, Amass, and DNSDumpster are used to enumerate subdomains and gather DNS information.

Active Reconnaissance

Comprehensive network scanning using Nmap helps identify live hosts, open ports, and services. Enumerating services and gathering banner information helps identify potential vulnerabilities and misconfigurations.

Identifying Original IP Addresses

Identifying the original IP addresses behind a WAF or firewall is a critical step in penetration testing. This process involves analyzing DNS data and leveraging third-party services to trace back to the true origin of the web application or API server.

DNS Analysis 

Tools like Amass, Sublist3r, and DNSRecon help identify subdomains and associated IP addresses. Historical DNS data from services like SecurityTrails, PassiveTotal, and VirusTotal can uncover previous IP addresses.

Third-Party Services 

Services like Shodan can help find the original IP address by searching for server headers or SSL certificate details. BGP looking glass services can trace the network path and identify the origin IP.

Vulnerability Identification Phase

The vulnerability identification phase is essential for pinpointing weaknesses within the target environment. This phase involves both network and application scanning to uncover potential security flaws that could be exploited.

Network Scanning

Manual probing of network services to identify open ports, services, and potential vulnerabilities is crucial. Tools like Nmap, Amap, and Netcat assist in fingerprinting services and identifying potential vulnerabilities.

Application Scanning

Thorough manual testing is performed to identify logic flaws, advanced injection attacks, and other vulnerabilities that automated tools might miss.

API Testing

Custom API requests are crafted and analyzed to identify vulnerabilities. Manual testing covers common API vulnerabilities, including broken authentication, authorization issues, rate limiting, and input validation flaws, ensuring coverage of the OWASP API Security Top 10 vulnerabilities.

Bypassing the WAF/Firewall

Bypassing the WAF or firewall is a critical step in penetration testing to ensure that protective measures do not hinder the identification of vulnerabilities. This phase involves using various techniques to evade detection and bypass security controls.

Payload Obfuscation

Encoding techniques such as URL encoding, Base64 encoding, and character obfuscation are used to bypass WAF rules. Burp Suite extensions like WAF Bypass and Turbo Intruder can automate payload obfuscation and bypass attempts.

Parameter Pollution

Testing for HTTP parameter pollution by sending multiple parameters with the same name or injecting unexpected characters. Tools like Param Miner and Arjun help identify parameter pollution vulnerabilities.

HTTP Method Manipulation

Using less common HTTP methods (e.g., HEAD, OPTIONS, TRACE) or methods with slight variations (e.g., POST instead of GET) can help bypass WAF filters. Tools like Burp Suite are utilized to modify and test various HTTP methods.

Header Manipulation

Modifying HTTP headers such as X-Forwarded-For, X-Original-URL, and X-Client-IP can bypass IP-based restrictions or mislead the WAF. Header injection vulnerabilities are tested using tools like Burp Suite and custom scripts.

Request Smuggling

Testing for HTTP request smuggling vulnerabilities involves sending crafted requests that exploit differences in how servers interpret request boundaries. Burp Suite’s HTTP Request Smuggler extension automates testing for request smuggling vulnerabilities.

Exploitation Phase

The exploitation phase is where identified vulnerabilities are actively exploited to gain unauthorized access or control over the target systems. This phase involves various techniques and tools to exploit network, application, and API vulnerabilities.

Network Exploitation

Attempting to exploit identified network vulnerabilities to gain access using tools like Metasploit and custom exploit scripts. Post-exploitation tools like Meterpreter are used to maintain access and gather further information.

Application Exploitation

Manually exploiting vulnerabilities such as SQL injection, XSS, CSRF, and command injection using obfuscated payloads and advanced techniques. Tools like SQLmap can be used for automated exploitation of SQL injection vulnerabilities.

API Exploitation

Using crafted API requests to exploit vulnerabilities such as improper input validation, authorization flaws, and business logic issues. Fuzzing techniques using tools like Burp Suite and OWASP ZAP help discover hidden vulnerabilities in API endpoints.

Reporting Phase

The reporting phase is essential for documenting and communicating the findings from the penetration test. This phase ensures that stakeholders are informed about the vulnerabilities, their potential impact, and the necessary remediation steps to enhance the security posture.

Documentation

Document all findings with detailed descriptions, evidence, and potential impact. Include steps to reproduce the vulnerabilities and suggestions for remediation. Ensure the report covers all aspects of the testing, including reconnaissance, vulnerability identification, exploitation, and post-exploitation.

Risk Assessment

Assess the risk level of each identified vulnerability based on its impact and likelihood of exploitation. Prioritize vulnerabilities based on their criticality and potential impact on the organization.

Remediation Recommendations

Provide actionable recommendations to fix the identified vulnerabilities. Include best practices for securing the application and APIs behind the firewall/WAF. Suggest improvements to the overall security posture of the organization, including patch management, secure coding practices, and regular security assessments.

Presentation

Present the findings to the stakeholders, ensuring that both technical and non-technical stakeholders understand the risks and remediation steps. Include an executive summary that highlights the key findings, risks, and recommendations.

Follow-Up Phase

The follow-up phase ensures that the vulnerabilities identified during the penetration test have been effectively addressed. This phase involves verifying the implementation of recommended patches and mitigations to confirm the resolution of security issues.

Patch Verification

Verify that the suggested patches and mitigations have been applied correctly by performing a re-test of the vulnerabilities.

Conclusion

Penetration testing applications and APIs behind a WAF/firewall is a complex process that requires a thorough understanding of various techniques and tools. By following this advanced methodology, security professionals can effectively identify and exploit vulnerabilities, providing organizations with valuable insights to improve their security posture.

Discover more from SecureLayer7 - Offensive Security, API Scanner & Attack Surface Management

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Enable Notifications OK No thanks